Discrepancies
There are discrepancies as it is confirmed no roll was made out by the Japanese, please read the two pages of Minute Sheet 43/44. This put more doubt of finding a definite outcome.
My data contains 606 names, eight although being on the 600 Gunner Party list did not leave Singapore in the Kenkon Maru. Two are not confirmed as being in the party, another six could not be found in the Commonwealth War Graves database, one is reported as dying in the CWGC as the 1943/03/05 but can not be confirmed as being in the party.
Place
|
Survived
|
Died
|
Ship to Rabaul
|
|
1
|
Rabaul
|
18
|
64
|
Ballale Island within CWG & KEW
|
0
|
504
|
Unknown to CWG
|
|
5 (Solomons/Ballale)
|
Not confirmed
|
|
2
|
Total in my database
|
18
|
576
|
If the six unknown names are not counted or the two not confirmed, plus the right date but not confirmed, add these to the missing names, there are 18 of the Gunners Party unaccounted for.
There could be a number of reasons for this, Alf does write however, 517 went to Ballale Island, but with new information it could have been 512, as 5 were said to have been killed in the Solomon Islands. With no information surviving Ballale as the Japanese destroyed all documentation, none of the prisoners on Ballale survived and all the reclaimed bodies were missing their ‘Dog Tags’ (service information always warn). The answer to the missing 18 or misspelt names is unfortunately unknown. But it was reported after the war that C.F. Pike was taken off the ship leaving Singapore as there was not enough space, this could account for the missing names.
On List But Did Not Sail With 600 Gunners Party
Aitchison, Thomas Taylor, Gunner, 1603409 - June Party 1942) to Thailand. Liberated and returned to UK 1945/10/16.
Bennett, Griffith, Gunner, 2053776 - Adam Park, Singapore. Transported 1942/10/25 overland to Thailand, No.4 Camp. Liberated Thailand. Liberated and returned to UK 1945/10/12.
Jackson, William, Gunner, 1768884 - Taken off list as in hospital with dysentery.
Johnson, Anthony, Lance Bombardier, 863857 - CWGC list as dying in Japan 1942/04/24.
Jones, Thomas Rhys, Gunner, 1605160, 3 H.A.A. Regiment - Survived in Changi till liberated..
Parker, Edgar John, Lance Bombardier, 1705900 - Taken off because of fever. Transported 1942/10/25 overland to Thailand, No.4 Camp. Liberated Thailand.
Pass, Sidney Charles, Sergeant, 4914924 - Too many, taken off list.
Pike, Charles Fred, Signalman, 2366441, att. 35 LAA RA - Too many taken, taken off list. Transported 1942/10/25 overland to Thailand, No.4 Camp. Liberated Thailand.
Winter, Albert Peter, Gunner, 1479522 - Taken out of Party the morning of sailing by our MO because of poor eyesight. Transported 1942/10/25 overland to Thailand, No.4 Camp. Liberated Thailand.
Wyatt, John, Gunner, 822829 - Transported 1942/10/25 to Thailand.
Left at Rabaul
Ahern, P, Lance Bombardier, 851969 - Rabaul. Arrived UK 1945/12/03
Dunne, William, Bombardier, 3850905 - Rabaul. Arrived UK 1945/12/17.
Nolan, Patrick, Lance Sergeant, 845353 - Rabaul. Arrived UK 1945/12/03.
Information
KEW:-
WO 361/773 - Solomon Islands: unaccounted for prisoners of war, who embarked at Singapore, 18 October 1942
WO 361/774 - Solomon Islands: unaccounted for prisoners of war, who embarked at Singapore (page 258).
WO 361/2206 - Prisoners of war, Far East: 600 party, overseas from Changi, Singapore on 18 October 1942.
|